While invasive predatory freshwater fishes have caused devastating damage to native freshwater species, ref marine invasive fishes are relatively uncommon and their ecological effects are largely unknown. Aquarium releases and ballast-water transport are the two most likely pathways of tropical marine fish introductions in the Caribbean and are likely to be equally important pathways in other regions.ref
Over the last several years, interest in the impacts of marine invasive fishes has increased dramatically due to the introduction of two closely related species of predatory lionfish (Pterois volitans and P. miles) from their native range in the Indo-Pacific to the Western Atlantic. While it is unknown how the lionfish were introduced, research suggests that several individual lionfish were released from an aquarium during Hurricane Andrew in 1992. ref
Since their release, lionfish have spread rapidly from Florida along the eastern United States and south into the Caribbean. ref Their range currently includes Rhode Island to Florida along the eastern US, the Bahamas, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, Lesser Antilles, Cayman Islands, Jamaica, Columbia, Costa Rica, Belize, Venezuela, and Mexico. ref
Recent research highlights the impacts of invasive lionfish to coral reef ecosystems in the Caribbean region. Such impacts include decreased survival of native reef animals due to predation and competition, which reduces the recruitment success of native coral reef fishes.ref
Lionfish have few natural predators in their native range, and therefore there are few native Atlantic and Caribbean species that could act as significant potential predators of lionfish. ref In the Caribbean and Atlantic, natural lionfish predators, like groupers, are overfished and are unlikely to reduce lionfish populations and their associated ecological impacts.
Other Marine Invasive Fish
Thirty-four species of marine fishes have been introduced into Hawai‘ian waters and almost 60% of these have become established. ref Of the introduced marine fishes, nearly 40% were intentionally introduced as food fish, bait fish, or aquatic weed control, ref including three species of marine fishes introduced by the State as food fish: Ta‘ape (Lutjanus kasmira/blueline snapper), toau (Lutjanus fulvus/blacktail snapper) and roi (Cephalopholis argus/peacock grouper).
Some researchers and fishers suggest that the introduction of these species has resulted in a decrease in fish abundance and associated catch of other important food fish species. While studies conducted to date have failed to document a strong biological impact on native fisheries in Hawai‘i from the introduction of these species, ref there is still widespread debate on this issue. In response, The Nature Conservancy and the University of Hawai‘i are currently conducting a “roi removal” experiment where all invasive roi have been removed from a series of reefs on Hawai‘i Island and the response of the native fish community is being tracked over time (see results).
Several other species were introduced in Hawai‘i, including tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus), sardine (Sardinella marquesensis), mullet (Valamugil engeli) and goatfish (Upeneus vittatus). The ecological effects of these species on Hawai‘i’s native coastal and marine ecosystems are unknown, although the mullet may be displacing native mullet (Mugil cephalus) in some estuaries. ref
Ecological and Socioeconomic Impacts
Few studies have assessed the ecological and socioeconomic impacts of invasive marine fishes and studies that have been conducted focused primarily on temperate regions compared to tropical regions. ref Assessing these impacts, as opposed to simply documenting the presence, abundance, and distribution of such species is an urgent research priority.
The potential ecological impacts of marine invasive fish include decreased survival of native reef animals via predation and competition, reduced recruitment success of native coral-reef fishes, and the potential to decrease abundance of ecologically important species (e.g., herbivores) that are vital to support reef resilience by preventing algae overgrowing corals.
Socioeconomic impacts of marine invasive fish include costs associated with combating, controlling and eradicating invasive species, and potential declines in fisheries for native fishes.
Global Marine Invasive Species Assessment — Global database with information on over 330 marine invasive species, including non-native distributions by marine ecoregion, invasion pathways, and ecological impact and other threat scores.
Caribbean response to lionfish invasion (scroll to bottom of page for downloadable PPTs for individual Caribbean countries related to lionfish status and management)
St. Eustatius National Marine Park: Lionfish Response Plan (pdf, 2.7M)
St. Maarten Nature Foundation Lionfish Response Plan (pdf, 4.2M)